Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Abandoned Albums Podcast's avatar

Thanks so much for this Brad! It's always a pleasure!

Expand full comment
Ellen from Endwell's avatar

I have to agree with PeDupre -- don't mess with perfection!

Keith's explanation of what makes the song special was great. Things I hadn't noticed or thought about.

I would add that, for me being driven by emotion and feeling, I find it thrilling and get hooked when the song reaches "I just can't find the answers" -- it literally soars and the lyrics at that point set up a narrative hook. What will he decide? Or will he?

Then he makes up his mind, yes let's do it, let's be together, but -- wait a second -- now he has to convince her because she's left him. Come back to me! It's an age-old, highly relatable, and brilliant story in one little song. Boy can't make up his mind, girls says forget it and leaves, boy is jolted into making up hjs mind. (Giving you the girl 'take' here!)

Only Bert Heerink came close for me, by using what sounds to me like the exact same arrangement. None of the other arrangements really got what made this special.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts